Kaitlin Nares is the founder of Nares Law Group (formerly Hagen Nares PLLC). Kaitlin is known for her compassion, professionalism, and clear communication. Kaitlin founded Nares Law Group as the culmination of her passion for the law and her desire to help families that have been severely injured at no fault of their own.
Kaitlin is experienced going toe to toe with the nation’s largest insurance companies. These companies have chosen profit over safety—resulting in catastrophic consequences for families. Kaitlin’s area of expertise includes truck wreck litigation and traumatic brain injuries. These are some of the toughest civil cases. They require a mastery of the laws, regulations, science, and medical literature. Kaitlin is a trial lawyer and willing to hold these large companies accountable. Her goal is to change laws and policies to make our communities safer.
Kaitlin began her legal career in Manhattan by litigating in the Southern District of New York. Kaitlin has been in courtrooms for over a decade. Kaitlin is featured in the award-winning documentary False Confessions for her litigation work in some of the country’s most notorious civil rights cases. Kaitlin is known for her calm demeanor, being quick on her feet, and outworking her opponents.
Kaitlin empathizes with her clients because she identifies with her clients. As a mother, Kaitlin understands that countless people are waking up in the middle of the night worried about themselves or their injured spouses and children. They are worried about mounting medical bills, missed calls from debt collectors, lost work, and the run-around from insurance companies. Kaitlin believes that these people deserve a caring and patient advocate.
Outside of the courtroom, Kaitlin loves being a CEO and business owner; spending quality time with her husband, Paul, and two sons, Brody and Noah; and exploring the Rocky Mountains.
When families face devastating injuries, they often feel powerless against insurance companies and corporations. This is where Kaitlin Nares excels. She has successfully represented clients in cases involving:
Her trial-tested approach means she does not accept the first offer that comes from an insurance adjuster. Instead, she digs deep into the evidence, consults with experts, and builds strong narratives that resonate with juries. She understands that trials are about more than facts—they are about people and the truth behind what they have suffered.
Not all attorneys are created equal. Many lawyers market themselves as “personal injury attorneys,” but few have real courtroom experience. Insurance companies know the difference. They often keep track of which attorneys are willing to take cases to trial and which ones settle every time.
Kaitlin Nares is an experienced trial attorney who has earned respect from both judges and opposing counsel. Her willingness to prepare for trial signals strength and gives her clients greater negotiating power. When Kaitlin enters the courtroom, insurance companies know they cannot intimidate her or minimize her client’s injuries.
This trial-readiness benefits her clients in several ways:
At Nares Law Group, results matter because they change lives. Kaitlin’s track record demonstrates her ability to achieve justice for her clients. Each successful verdict or settlement is not just a legal win—it is a restoration of dignity, financial security, and hope for the future.
Clients trust Kaitlin because she:
This trust is the foundation of her practice. Families turn to Kaitlin Nares not only because of her legal skills, but also because they know she genuinely cares about their recovery and well-being.
A serious injury affects more than the victim—it touches every member of the family. Medical bills, lost income, emotional trauma, and long-term care needs create a ripple effect. Kaitlin Nares understands these burdens and approaches each case with both skill and compassion.
She has helped families secure compensation for:
Her dedication goes beyond winning cases. Kaitlin ensures that families feel supported through every stage of the process. From the initial consultation to the final verdict, she communicates openly, explains legal strategies clearly, and empowers her clients to make informed decisions.
Vanderbilt University
St. John's School of Law
Colorado
Texas
New York
